
PoTC: On Stranger Tides
Woooooooooooooo!! Pirates of the Caribbean! I love this franchise. In this fourth installment, Jack Sparrow – sorry, Captain Jack Sparrow – finds himself en route to the Fountain of Youth, by order of the English crown. Well, at least that’s the synopsis for the first 15 minutes. Let’s try again: In this fourth installment, after about 15 minutes, Jack Sparrow instead finds himself en route to the Fountain of Youth, forcefully enlisted by the beautiful Penelope Cruz, who is apparently Blackbeard’s daughter. Abandoning the horrid love triangle that caused so many to turn their backs on their beloved pirate trilogy, OST only brings back four cast members from the previous installments – including… wait for it… my favorite, Barbossa (I mean, seriously, if you don’t like Barbossa what’s wrong with you). Anyways, everyone wants the Fountain of Youth. Blah blah blah.
If you truly know me, then you know that I loved the original trilogy. Cheesy love triangles be damned, I absolutely loved the sword fights and the intrigue, and those were perhaps the first real time I ever just switched off my brain and enjoyed the movies for what they were. I’ll admit that everyone has their irks and love triangles simply isn’t one of mine (remember, I love horror films and chick flicks).
Anywho, there were several things that really stood out about this film. First of all, the new cast members really set up a good jumping off point for the next film. There’s a new love interest, of course, and this time you’re actually kind of “awww” about the whole thing – luckily, it’s not a love triangle though, which is what I think a lot of people disliked about previous films. Geoffrey Rush and Kevin McNally are two of the four returners, and their presence was sorely missed during the absence of another PoTC film. In this film, Rush has a more center-stage role and he certainly takes advantage of it. I myself was glad they gave us more Rush – his acting, or maybe it’s just his character, is certainly one of the better highlights of this production.
The music score in this film is astounding, but when are the “nectar to our ears” Hans Zimmer not kicking ass with his musical embodiment of notes and crescendos? The guy is a goldmine and if you listen to Pandora, and you enjoy motivational “I’m going to kick this essay’s ass” kind of music, then you gotta seriously consider putting Mr. Zimmer as one of the “artists”.
Everything in the film was pretty top notch; the sets were beautiful, the acting kept the story going enough, the music was perfect (see my nerdgasm one paragraph up), and the story was a good one. So why would I give this film only a 3.75/5? Simply put, this film was the same as it’s previous counterparts and not as good.
While I believe it was a good idea to start up again with a different cast and try and go in a new direction, I believe the attempt was “admirable” at best. As previously mentioned, you have four returning cast members… but they do what they’ve been doing since the first film – betraying, lying, cheating, stealing, and switching loyalties faster than SAW’s fanbase dwindled. The formula is somewhat tiring and barely holds up on its own. As for new characters….. mehh. Ian McShane plays the dreaded Blackbeard, a shoe-in for replacing Davy Jones and the English as adversaries to Jack Sparrow, right? Wrong. If I’m not mistaken, fans of the trilogy loved the villains from the previous films, correct? Everyone loves Barbossa for obvious reasons, the English’s Cutler Beckett (Tom Hollander) was a villain, but fans loved his manipulative manner, and Davy Jones was ultimately found to be a sad soul that you kind of sympathized with or perhaps even feared. Blackbeard is none of these things, and you mostly just can’t wait for him to be defeated/killed. Same goes with Penelope Cruz, who plays opposite Sparrow as an old flame. All I have to say is she’s as annoying as you think she’ll be after watching the trailer. Her character has a pretty shallow background, and while Cruz is certainly a talented actress, her character is pretty boring. There is a “William” of the film, but he’s more of a tertiary background character and Sparrow doesn’t even really exchange words with him – it’s basically a side plot.
I know it seems like I contradicted myself with the pros and cons, so let’s re-cap. Jack Sparrow is still amazing, Barbossa returns with a better center-stage kind of aspect (and is very lovable in this), Ian McShane and Penelope Cruz are boring, “William” (as in “not William”) is a very distanced side plot, the music is utterly astounding, the visuals are gorgeous, the formula of betrayal and trust is the same, the fight scenes are alright, and the story is a good one for the most part. Oh, and I should add that Astrid Berges-Frisbey is astoundingly beautiful as the mermaid Syrena (perhaps named alla “siren” from the Odyssey story). I would say that this film is worth seeing in theaters… but it won’t kill you to wait until it comes out on DVD. This was first and foremost a filler for the 5th film, which I believe a script has already been turned in and pre-production is in the works. 3.75/5